The Apprentice - Season 3

Your Comments on the First Show


Cast Members Team Magna (Book Smarts) - Week 1 

   

        


E-Mail your take to apprentice@kevinhogan.com

If you didn't see the season opener, don't worry. Watch the next show and email us your thoughts then!

The Premiere Show  (Todd is fired!)

This season's twist is an interesting (and controversial) one! Half the group has a pedigree (college-educated), and the other half are high-school educated entrepreneurs with real experience (earning 3 times as much as the other group put together!)

On the premiere show, we met all the contestants and got to see them taking over a fast food joint for the day while launching a new product.

Elementary mistakes downed the college educated team. With only 2 people on register during the lunch rush, they were basically forced to turn away frustrated customers. Not impressive.

The other team won points with the staff by establishing rapport (you might have heard the other team thinks they are better than us - let's show them!)

I see trouble with interactions between the players already. (Mostly on the college-grad team.)

Drop me a note and let me know what YOU thought of the first week. We'll publish signed responses on our site before this week's show.

Kevin Hogan  01/24/05

 

- Your Comments:

 

"I couldn't believe the rah-rah of the college grad team which turned out to be a bunch of whine-whine. What was that one black-haired woman doing crying about having to send one of the contestants away? Isn't that the whole point. She should just sacrifice herself now if that's the way she's going to be with each Board Room! 

Danny was annoying, but some of his out-of-the-box thinking was in the end satisfactory (they did get customers in the door.)

Todd deserved to be fired. Sitting on the job? No.

Will be fun to see the rest! Looks like a good group of people."

Jennifer Martin

 

"Another season of the Apprentice begins and the first episode could not have presented two more different teams. There were a couple of issues that sprang to my mind right away:
 
1. Characters: As the show enters the 3rd season, clearly candidates are seeing beyond the finale towards what lies waiting for those that don't get the job. Failure on the show still means 15 minutes of fame, or more if you can stretch that out. This is exemplified by what I call "characters." Perhaps Wacky Danny is a great example of that, but it extends to "Bowtie" Bren and fashion-plate Erin. The desire to stand out has to be a huge potential liability at this point, where being seen as too pretty (Season 2's Jen, though not her fault) or quirky (Raj- loved the guy, but the clothes made him an easy mark) can put you under a light that may ultimately lead to your demise. Save the sparkle for the tasks and do your job.
2. Insincere leaders: Todd gave a rah-rah speech prior to opening the store. He used phrases like "I'm proud of you." Such praise is meaningless until after you have led a team, after rapport has been established, and after you gain credibility with others. First task pm's are the pm b/c of their proven skill. You have to earn the right to be proud of your team. Otherwise it is hollow and meaningless. I think the only reason why Danny was in the boardroom was because his marketing performance was such a freakshow. Otherwise it would have been Todd by a landslide.
3. Personality: Danny is an early "fire" sure-thing. His marketing partner Stephanie made a big mistake about turning on him, perhaps because she saw the attention turn away from Todd onto Danny. Brian from Net Worth is cheerful, but his Viking Hat shtick was not emblematic of good bargaining skills but a lack of focus. Additionally, his use of strong profanity at dinner is not a good sign. Trump didn't say anything, and maybe doesn't care that much, but it marked Brian as having less tact. This will hurt him (by the way, I always thought that story about Trump paying off someone's mortgage was Urban Legend).
 
I think that the street-smart team leader John has already established himself as a strong contender. He motivated his team in a personal way, delegated like a pro, and made things happen. He was involved, a real entrepreneur, and not a delegater like Todd.his team. At this stage in the competition, this is a must. It engenders trust and will build the capital he will need later on. I think he has a decent shot of getting to the final 2. Everyone else was a cipher."
 
Joe Lowry, Jr.
 

"Thank god for MSNBC.  I travel most Thursday nights and it gives me a chance to catch up on the Apprentice on reruns.

I've only seen the first episode so far.  And here are my observations.

During the first two seasons I couldn't believe how unbelievably dull witted all the contestants were.  Overeducated robots.

And this group.  It instantly reminded me of one of my favorite Robert Kiyosaki ("Rich Dad, Poor Dad) quotes.  "The A students end up working for the C students and the B students work for the government."

I felt like I was watching a remake of the movie "Big."  Grown up bodies with the minds and experience of children.  And not very bright children.  Children who were taught to listen well and imitate but never think on their own.  Their privileged (read pampered, unchallenging and "looking good at any cost") upbringings make them good for corporate cogs but little else.

I will say they inspired me in one way.  I've thinking about becoming a 21st Century Corporate Carlos Castenada (SP?). Why? It's obvious that these people are each living a very separate reality of their own.  There has to be a book in there somewhere.

I'm tempted to say (and all of these thoughts come from my own experience and beliefs) that the contestants are poster children for the dumbing down of education.

In the past the kind of ignorance I saw on this show could be blamed on self-centeredness and me-first.  But they look totally oblivious to what's going on. Like the guy who got fired and was wandering around not knowing what to do and making excuses about not being trained had the same dumb look on his face Bush did in 911.

When you're self centered at least you recognize other people are around and can adapt if you want.  But when you are oblivious, you wander through life like in a pinball machine bouncing around and not really accomplishing much.  But at the same time, that stupidity acts as a buffer of sorts.  Especially when all your friends and others around you are the same kind of sheep.

Keep up the great work."

 John

        

Click arrow to continue or go to previous page

 

Team Net Worth (Street Smarts) - Week 1

 

        

 


Thank you for coming !


See our store for specials!

Affiliate Program


Easy, Superfast, Cash in Your Pocket!



   E-mail Your Opinion

 | Join Our Mailing List |  | Kevinhogan.com |  | More on Body Language |


© 2005 Network 3000 Publishing - All Rights Reserved